Skip to main content
Centers

of attention

Office

digital

24 hour emergency

900 269 269

Fraternidad-Muprespa
  • Get to know us
    • Who we are
    • Mission, Vision and Values
    • Organization chart
    • Governing Bodies
    • Transparency Law
    • +compromiso
    • Agreements with other MCSS
    • Telephone numbers and addresses
    • Annual Report and Annual Report
    • Strategic plan
    • Code of Ethics and Conduct
    • Year 2022 "The Mutual that takes care of you"
  • CSR
    • Commitment to CSR
    • Commitment to diversity
    • Commitment to sustainability
    • Commitment to the SDGs
    • CSR and SDG Report
  • Certifications
    • Fraternidad-Muprespa Policies
    • ISO 9001 Quality
    • Customer Satisfaction ISO 10002
    • Environment ISO 14001
    • Verified Carbon Footprint-GHG Protocol
    • ISO 27001 and ENS Information Security
    • QH Accreditation**
    • DIGA/AIS Accessibility
    • Occupational Health and Safety ISO 45001
    • Digital Pact
  • Labor-Digital Wellbeing Observatory

24-hour emergency service

900 269 269

Care centers

Centers

of attention

Office

digital

24 hour emergency

900 269 269

  • Get to know us
    • Who we are
    • Mission, Vision and Values
    • Organization chart
    • Governing Bodies
    • Transparency Law
    • +compromiso
    • Agreements with other MCSS
    • Telephone numbers and addresses
    • Annual Report and Annual Report
    • Strategic plan
    • Code of Ethics and Conduct
    • Year 2022 "The Mutual that takes care of you"
  • CSR
    • Commitment to CSR
    • Commitment to diversity
    • Commitment to sustainability
    • Commitment to the SDGs
    • CSR and SDG Report
  • Certifications
    • Fraternidad-Muprespa Policies
    • ISO 9001 Quality
    • Customer Satisfaction ISO 10002
    • Environment ISO 14001
    • Verified Carbon Footprint-GHG Protocol
    • ISO 27001 and ENS Information Security
    • QH Accreditation**
    • DIGA/AIS Accessibility
    • Occupational Health and Safety ISO 45001
    • Digital Pact
  • Labor-Digital Wellbeing Observatory
  • Company
  • Self-employed
  • Worker
  • Consulting
  • Corporate portal
Justice
Comparte
Volver

The TSJ of Madrid condemns the company for violating the fundamental right to physical integrity of a worker subjected to work overload and stress

The ruling confirms the compensated termination of the contract for abusive working conditions, harassment and work overload that affected the employee's health, also imposing compensation for moral damages.

The appeal 58/2024, filed against the sentence handed down by the Social Court No. 2 of Madrid in the ordinary procedure, is resolved (orders 482/2023).

The plaintiff, Ms. Enriqueta, had worked in an insurance company since September 6, 2020, initially being in charge of processing claims for a client insurance company. As of May 2021, he progressively assumed more responsibilities, including the complete management of damage recovery files, using the client entity's own IT tools and answering telephone calls.

Between August and September 2021, the company announced the implementation of a penalty system for delays of more than 23 seconds in answering calls, which further increased work pressure. At the end of 2022, a total of 4,411 files were managed, although the team had only grown from 3 to 5 members, being insufficient to cope with the workload.

In March 2022, Ms. Enriqueta received brief training on “criminal compliance” and data processing. Subsequently, on December 14, 2022, he was subject to a disciplinary sanction that was withdrawn after a conciliation agreement.

On January 5, 2023, he began a medical leave due to Temporary Disability, after having received specialized psychiatric care since July 2021. In June 2023, a psychiatric report confirmed that his health condition was affected by abusive working conditions, harassment and violation of fundamental rights. Pharmacological treatment was intensified in September 2023 due to symptoms of anxiety, depression, insomnia and fear of the future.

Ms. Enriqueta, in the statement of claim, requested the termination of the employment relationship in accordance with article 50 of the Workers' Statute. In the instance, the violation of his fundamental right to physical and mental integrity was recognized (article 15 of the Spanish Constitution). The initial ruling, clarified by a subsequent order, established compensation of €24,600.71 for the termination of the contract and an additional compensation of €10,000 for moral damages.

The company filed an appeal, which was challenged by the worker.The main question to be resolved It focused on determining whether the worker had the right to terminate her contract with compensation, with additional compensation for damages due to the violation of her fundamental right to physical integrity by the company, by assigning her an excessive workload. The company alleged several reasons in the appeal, including irregularities in the processing of the case and in the evaluation of the evidence.

The lower court ruling concluded that the company compromised the worker's health by increasing the workload without increasing sufficient human resources, which affected her physical well-being. Furthermore, the company's activity coordination was aware of the situation and did not carry out a risk assessment or implement specific measures for stress management, providing training to prevent damage and avoid risks. Also, he highlighted that the “criminal compliance” training provided by the company was insufficient, which caused clear damage to Ms. Enriqueta's health.

The TSJ of Madrid, dismissed the company's claims, considering that there were no irregularities in the judicial process,affirming that the lower court ruling made an interpretation and application of the regulations completely in accordance with the law.

The Court maintained the interpretation of the instance, the worker was subjected to a risk situation that represented a violation of the fundamental right to physical integrity of art. 15, in a business practice that, in this case, the company failed to fulfill its duty to protect the health of the worker by overloading her with an excessive workload, impossible to assume, without applying adequate prevention measures, which constituted unjustified and reprehensible non-compliance with the regulations for the prevention of occupational risks.

In the sentence,cites previous jurisprudence of the TSJ of the Canary Islands of 4.6.2018, appeal number 1739/17 in which it is stated Psychosocial risks are work contexts with a high probability of damaging the health of workers. According to the European Agency for Safety and Health at Work, these risks include aspects of the design and organization of work that can cause physical, mental or social harm. Work overload is an example of a psychosocial factor and stress is an example of a psychosocial risk, which can lead to damage, which is the injury or illness caused by the failure to prevent the causative factors (physical ailments or mental pathologies, anxiety, depression, etc.).

Fecha sentencia
September 2024
Nº de recurso
58/2024
STSJ_M_10372_2024.pdf

Previene

SAFETY AND HEALTH

Patient

PORTAL

Entrepreneur

PORTAL

Advisor's

CORNER

Health

Corner

Hospital

PORTAL

Advocate

of the mutualist

Contact

with us

Centers

of attention

Certificados y acreditaciones

Certificación de calidad-ISO-9001 AENOR
Certificación ISO 14001 de AENOR
Certificación ISO 27001 de AENOR
Certificación Huella de carbono de AENOR
Certificación AENOR 10002
Certificación Pacto digital
Certificación Compromiso con la diversidad
Certificación WCAG1AA
Certificación UNGC
Certificación Seguridad de la información
❮
❯

The Mutual caring for you

The Mutua that takes care of you

  • the company
  • autonomous
  • the worker
  • Counseling
  • Corporate portal

  • Compliance Portal
  • Transparent portal
  • ORP Portal (Previene)
  • Entrepreneur Portal
  • hospital portal
  • patient portal
  • Advisor's Corner
  • health corner

  • Who are we?
  • Work at the mutual
  • press room
  • Site map

Menú redes sociales v20

  • Facebook
  • X
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
  • instagram

Contractor profile | Cookies | Legal notice | Privacy

Social Security Collaborating Mutual Insurance Company, 275. Fraternidad-Muprespa 2026

Save
English
  • Castellano
  • Català
  • Euskara
  • Galego